If you want the look of a fireplace without a gas line, a chimney or any combustion, the two realistic choices are a water vapor fireplace and a conventional electric fireplace. Both can finish a wall in a condo, a brownstone parlor or a restaurant where a gas or wood fireplace is not practical (and in New York City, where new wood is not permitted and vent-free gas is not allowed, that is a lot of rooms). They create the flame in very different ways, and that difference drives everything else: realism, heat, installation and upkeep.
The short answer
Pick water vapor when flame realism, depth and a cool, open-looking fire are the priority. Pick a conventional electric fireplace when supplemental heat, the simplest installation and the widest range of sizes and budgets matter more.
Key takeaways
- Water vapor makes a three-dimensional flame from cool mist and light; conventional electric makes a flat flame effect behind glass. Vapor wins on realism, electric wins on simplicity.
- Heat is model by model: the Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear has a built-in heater, the NetZero Waterplace has none, and most conventional electric fireplaces include one.
- Every vapor unit needs a water plan (hand-filled reservoir or a plumbed quarter-inch line) and a monthly cleaning habit. Electric needs an outlet and a dust cloth.
- Both are legal in New York City apartments because neither one burns anything. A hardwired or plumbed install still goes through licensed trades and your board.
- Electric has the widest range of sizes and budgets of any fireplace type. Vapor starts higher and makes sense when the flame is the architectural centerpiece.
In this guide
What is a water vapor fireplace?
A water vapor fireplace uses water and light to create a three-dimensional flame. An ultrasonic transducer turns water in a reservoir into a fine, cool mist. LEDs light the mist from below so it reads as flame and smoke as it rises and drifts. Because the effect is made from water rather than combustion, there is no fuel, no flue and no hot flame. Most units run on ordinary household power.
Water vapor is the fireplace we specify most often in luxury media walls, custom built-ins, restaurants, lobbies and bedrooms, anywhere the fireplace is an architectural focal point first and a heater second (or not at all).
Two platforms we stock and display are Dimplex Opti-Myst and NetZero Waterplace. They are not interchangeable. The Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear fireplaces include a fan-forced heater and can run in "flame only" or "flame and heat" mode, while the NetZero Waterplace is built as a zero-heat vapor flame. Compare the exact model rather than assuming every water vapor fireplace works the same way.
What is a conventional electric fireplace?
A conventional electric fireplace simulates a flame behind glass with LEDs, reflective media, projection or, on the newest models, a high-resolution screen. Most include an electric heater that can run with or without the flame effect, which is why electric is the practical choice when you want ambience and warmth from the same box.
Electric is also the broadest category we sell. There are linear electric fireplaces from about 40 inches to over 100 inches wide, traditional electric fireboxes for mantel openings, wall-mounted units, built-in electric fireplaces and outdoor-rated models. That range is the biggest practical advantage over water vapor: there is a size and a budget for nearly every room.

How do they compare side by side?
| Factor | Water vapor | Conventional electric |
|---|---|---|
| Flame | Illuminated mist, three-dimensional, visible from multiple angles | LED or screen-based effect behind glass, viewed from the front |
| Heat | Model dependent: Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear has a heater, NetZero Waterplace does not | Most models include a heater, usually 120V plug-in or 240V hardwired |
| Touch safety | Flame itself is cool mist; open designs possible | Glass stays cool, but heater outlet discharges warm air |
| Installation | Power plus a water plan: fill a reservoir or plumb a line | Power and a framed opening; plug-in models need only an outlet |
| Maintenance | Refill or plumb, clean the reservoir, replace wear parts like mist makers | Dust the vents and glass |
| Range of sizes and budgets | Narrower, premium | Widest of any fireplace category |
The six differences that matter
1. Which flame looks more real?
Water vapor advantage: because the illuminated mist rises and moves in three dimensions, the flame has real depth. You can see it from the side, from above, and in see-through and peninsula installations. NetZero burners can be joined end to end for up to 20 feet of continuous flame, which no electric firebox does.
Electric advantage: premium electric fireplaces have become very convincing from the front, and they offer things vapor cannot: multiple flame and ember-bed colors, selectable media, and on screen-based units like the Modern Flames Orion, recorded footage of actual fire. If you want control over the look of the fire, electric gives you more switches to flip.
From our install team
Dark backgrounds sell vapor. The mist is lit from below, so a black glass liner or a dark firebox makes the flame pop; a white or mirrored interior washes it out. If the design calls for a light surround, keep the firebox interior dark and let the trim carry the color.
2. Which produces more heat?
If supplemental heat is a major goal, a conventional electric fireplace is the easier choice. Most include an integrated heater that runs independently of the flame.
Water vapor needs model-by-model attention. The Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear 66 pairs its vapor flame with a fan-forced heater rated 1,480 watts at 120V or 2,180 watts at 240V, and runs in flame-only or flame-and-heat mode. The NetZero Waterplace 40 is a no-heat decorative feature by design: water vapor, light, and nothing warm.
3. Which is safer to touch?
Because a water vapor flame is cool mist, the fire itself cannot burn anyone. That opens up designs that would never be appropriate around a gas or wood flame: open-top fireboxes, low hearths in family rooms, and installations directly below a television. It is also why hospitality designers like vapor in lobbies and dining rooms.
Conventional electric fireplaces also avoid combustion, but models with heaters discharge warm air from a vent, and the manufacturer's clearance to the TV above still applies. Many linear electric units are designed to sit under a television with the heater vent at the front or bottom for that reason.
4. What installation is required?
A conventional electric fireplace is the simpler install. Plug-in units need an outlet. Larger built-ins may want a dedicated circuit or 240V for full heater output, which is a licensed electrician's job in NYC, but there is no venting and no gas permit.
A water vapor fireplace needs electricity plus a water strategy. Reservoir models are filled by hand: the NetZero Waterplace 40 carries a 4.0 liter tank rated for about 20 hours of flame per fill. For longer or continuous operation, plumb it. The NetZero Waterplace Platinum includes direct-plumb components and an automatic drain pump, and the Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear accepts an optional plumbing kit on quarter-inch copper with an overflow sensor. Plan the water line and a drain during framing, not after the drywall is up.
5. What maintenance is involved?
Conventional electric fireplaces need almost nothing: keep the heater vents clear and the glass clean.
Water vapor systems have water-related upkeep. Reservoirs get refilled or plumbed, the tank should be cleaned on the manufacturer's schedule, and the ultrasonic mist maker and LED strips are wear items that eventually get replaced (NetZero's warranty excludes them for that reason). Water quality matters: hard water leaves mineral scale on the mist maker, but pure distilled water makes a weak flame, so follow the manual. NetZero specifies soft to moderately hard tap water and no distilled or reverse osmosis water; Dimplex allows distilled only with a pinch of salt added. On a plumbed unit in a hard-water area, add an inline softener or filter kit. None of this is difficult, but it is the ownership difference.
6. Which costs more, and which has more choice?
A conventional electric fireplace gives you the widest price range in the business, from compact plug-in units to 100 inch linear showpieces. Water vapor starts higher and makes the most sense when the three-dimensional flame and the architectural flexibility justify it. Larger custom vapor runs become the design element of the room rather than an appliance in a wall.
From our install team
On vapor jobs, the question we ask before anything else is "where does the water come from and where does it go?" A plumbed unit needs a supply line and, on some models, a drain. A reservoir unit needs a way to get a pitcher of water into it without pulling the trim off. Decide this while the wall is open.
Our recommended models
These are the units we show side by side in Maspeth and install most often. Each one earns its spot for a different reason, so match the label to what matters in your room.
Water vapor
Conventional electric
Water Vapor FireplacesDimplex Opti-MystNetZeroElectric FireplacesLinear Electric
Not sure what fits your space? Tell us the wall width, whether a TV goes above it, and whether you need heat. Book a free design consultation and we will help you narrow it down, or come see both flame effects running side by side in Maspeth.
Which should you choose?
Choose water vapor if:
- You want the most dimensional flame possible without combustion.
- The fireplace is mainly for ambience, or you have picked a model with heat and know it.
- You are building a custom media wall or an architectural feature, especially multi-sided, see-through or peninsula.
- You want an open-looking fire that is safe to approach, in a home with children or in a hospitality space.
Choose conventional electric if:
- You want useful supplemental heat from the fireplace.
- You want the simplest installation, often just an outlet.
- You have a tighter budget or a specific size to hit.
- You want a straightforward fireplace for a bedroom, family room, apartment, condo or renovation.
For a luxury feature where the flame itself is the centerpiece, we steer customers to water vapor, usually the Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear if they want heat or a NetZero Waterplace if they do not. For a fireplace that has to combine ambience, heat, an easy install and a sensible budget, a conventional linear electric is the better fit. On larger projects we often do both: vapor on the living room feature wall, conventional electric in the bedrooms. Start with the water vapor fireplace collection and the modern electric fireplace collection, then come see both flame effects running in our showroom before you commit.
Frequently asked questions
Do water vapor fireplaces produce heat?
Some do and some do not. The Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear includes a fan-forced heater and can run flame only or flame and heat. The NetZero Waterplace is a zero-heat flame effect. Check the exact model.
Do water vapor fireplaces need plumbing?
Not always. Reservoir models are filled by hand; the NetZero Waterplace 40 runs about 20 hours on its 4 liter tank. For long or continuous operation, a plumbed configuration (NetZero Platinum, or the Dimplex plumbing kit) is more convenient.
Can a water vapor fireplace go below a TV?
Yes, and it is one of the most common places we install them, because the flame is cool mist. Follow the fireplace and television manufacturers' requirements, and if the vapor unit includes a heater, treat the heater vent the same way you would on a conventional electric.
Which is more realistic, water vapor or electric?
For a three-dimensional moving flame with visible depth, water vapor. For customizable colors, ember effects and a clean screen-based presentation, a premium conventional electric fireplace can be the better fit.
Is a water vapor fireplace legal in a NYC apartment?
Yes. There is no combustion, no vent and no gas, so the city's fuel gas and chimney rules do not apply. Your building may still want to approve any built-in work, and a hardwired or plumbed install should be done by licensed trades.
What kind of water should I use?
The water the manual specifies, which is usually ordinary soft to moderately hard tap water. NetZero prohibits distilled and reverse osmosis water because the mist maker needs some dissolved minerals to work; Dimplex allows distilled with a pinch of salt. Hard well water scales the mist maker, so use a softener or filter kit on Long Island, New Jersey installs.
Does a water vapor fireplace make the room humid?
Not noticeably in normal use. The mist is fine and dissipates within inches of the flame. NetZero states there is no damaging humidity or moisture buildup on surrounding surfaces, and the Waterplace on display in our Maspeth showroom sits in finished millwork.
Talk to a specialist
See both flames running before you choose
We have been designing, selling, installing and servicing fire features and outdoor kitchens for over 30 years across New York City, Long Island, Westchester, New Jersey and lower Connecticut. Our Maspeth showroom runs water vapor and conventional electric fireplaces side by side, and our crews handle the framing, power and water on the install.
Book a free consultationCall 718-326-4328Showroom: 58-30 Maspeth Ave, Maspeth, Queens.
Related guides
Browse all buying guides and expert advice →
Written by the NYC Fireplaces & Outdoor Kitchens team. Last reviewed October 2026. We sell, install and service the products discussed here.
Sources:Dimplex Opti-Myst Linear specifications and installation guide, NetZero Waterplace NZW40 and NZWP40 specifications, Modern Flames Orion. Specifications change; always confirm with the manufacturer's current installation manual.






