Gozney, Alfa and Ooni come up in almost every pizza oven conversation we have, and each is built around a different idea of a backyard oven. Alfa builds Italian ovens with a real refractory brick floor. Gozney builds tightly engineered stone-floored ovens designed to be looked at. Ooni built the portable category and still leads it on range and value. All of our current ovens live in our pizza oven collection.
We sell and install Alfa and Gozney. We do not carry Ooni, so we describe it from Ooni's published specifications and consistent reviewer themes.
The short answer
Choose Alfa if you host and want two to five pizzas at once on Italian firebrick, with gas and an optional wood Hybrid Kit. Choose Gozney if you want the best single-pizza oven as a permanent, good-looking fixture: the Arc XL for propane simplicity, the Dome Gen 2 for wood and gas with 30 mm of stone. Choose Ooni if you want the widest range at the lowest entry point, including light portables, natural gas Koda models and an indoor electric oven. All three reach roughly 900 to 950°F; the real differences are capacity, floor mass and weight.
Key takeaways
- Capacity is the biggest split. Alfa's 2, 3, 4 and 5 Pizze ovens bake that many pizzas at once. Gozney and most Ooni ovens are one-pizza ovens.
- Floor mass matters more than peak temperature. Alfa uses refractory brick, Gozney uses 20 to 30 mm cordierite, and Ooni uses 15 to 20 mm cordierite.
- Weight tells you how permanent each oven is: Ooni Karu 2 at 33.6 lb, Gozney Arc XL at 58.5 lb, Gozney Dome Gen 2 at 136.6 lb, Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze at about 174 lb.
- Gozney and Ooni both offer one year of coverage that extends to five years when you register within 60 days.
In this guide
- Gozney vs Alfa vs Ooni at a glance
- Where does each brand fit?
- How many pizzas can each oven cook at once?
- Brick or cordierite: which floor cooks better?
- Which heats up fastest?
- Which is most flexible on fuel?
- Pizza ovens in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Long Island and Palm Beach County
- Our recommended models
- Which should you choose?
- Frequently asked questions
Gozney vs Alfa vs Ooni at a glance
Representative models from each brand, with figures from the manufacturers. Alfa floor sizes are for the gas versions.
| Oven | Pizzas at once | Floor | Fuel | Heat-up | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gozney Arc XL | One 16 in | 20 mm cordierite | Propane | 30 to 40 min | 58.5 lb |
| Gozney Dome Gen 2 | One 16 in | 30 mm cordierite | Propane, wood, charcoal | 40 to 45 min | 136.6 lb |
| Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze | Two | Refractory brick, 60 by 50 cm | Gas; wood with Hybrid Kit | About 30 min to 500°C | About 174 lb |
| Alfa Moderno 5 Pizze | Five | Refractory brick, 33.5 by 27.6 in | Gas; wood with Hybrid Kit | About 30 min | About 386 lb |
| Ooni Karu 2 Pro | One 16 in | 15 mm cordierite | Wood, charcoal; gas with burner | About 15 min | 62.6 lb |
| Ooni Koda 2 Max | One 20 in or three 10 in | 20 mm cordierite, 24 by 21 in | Propane or natural gas | Not published | 95 lb |
Where does each brand fit?
Alfa was founded in Italy in 1977 and builds its ovens in Anagni, south of Rome. Its Forninox construction pairs a stainless steel vault with HeatKeeper refractory brick made in Alfa's own Italian plant and ceramic fiber insulation. The Moderno is the rounded, colorful line, the Classico is the traditional dome, and the Futuro is the architectural one with a stainless arch, made to sit in an outdoor kitchen.
Gozney is a British company whose founder came up building restaurant ovens. Its Arc XL and Dome Gen 2 use removable cordierite, layered insulation and a lateral burner that rolls flame over the top of the pie. Stands, mantels and covers are designed as one system, and the ovens are meant to be seen. For a deeper look inside the lineup, see our Gozney Dome vs Arc vs Roccbox guide.
Ooni, from Scotland, made the affordable portable pizza oven a mainstream product. Today it sells the gas Koda 2 family (14, 18 and 24 inch), the multi-fuel Karu 2 family (12 and 16 inch) and the Volt 2, a 12 inch electric oven rated for indoor use. Bodies are powder-coated carbon steel with stainless internals. Reviewers describe Ooni as the value and range leader, quick to set up and easy to move, with a more utilitarian look than Gozney. Owners often mention learning to turn the flame down so the base does not scorch, which is true of any thin-stone oven at full heat.

How many pizzas can each oven cook at once?
Gozney's largest oven, the Dome XL Gen 2, takes one 18 inch pizza. The Dome Gen 2 and Arc XL take one 16 inch pie. Ooni's largest, the Koda 2 Max, has a 24 inch dual-zone floor that fits one 20 inch pizza or three 10 inch pies; the rest of the range is single-pizza. Alfa names its ovens by capacity: the Moderno 2 Pizze bakes two, the Moderno 3 Pizze three, the Classico 4 Pizze four, and the Moderno 5 Pizze five on a floor of 33.5 by 27.6 inches.
From our install team
A multi-pizza oven pays off only if the kitchen can keep up. Two people stretching and topping can feed a 4 Pizze; one cook alone ends up baking one pizza at a time. For a household of four or five, a single-pizza Gozney or a Moderno 2 Pizze is usually faster in practice.
Countertop pizza ovens Freestanding pizza ovens
Brick or cordierite: which floor cooks better?
This is the one useful thing we wish every buyer knew: the thickness and material of the floor matters more than the maximum temperature on the box. All three brands advertise around 900 to 950°F. What separates them is how much heat the floor stores and how quickly it recovers between pizzas.
Alfa's HeatKeeper brick stores a lot of heat and releases it gently, so the underside of a Neapolitan pie tends to come out spotted rather than scorched, and the oven holds steady for bread. Gozney's Dome uses 30 mm cordierite, which recovers well for back-to-back pizzas, while the Arc XL uses 20 mm. Ooni's Karu 2 family uses 15 mm cordierite and the Koda 2 Pro and Max use 20 mm. Thinner stone heats faster and keeps the oven light, but it gives up heat sooner when you cook pizza after pizza.
Our view: for a weeknight pizza or two, all three floors are excellent once you learn the dial. For a party, or for bread and roasting, more mass wins, and brick has the most.
Which heats up fastest?
Ooni, by the published numbers. Ooni rates the Karu 2 at about 15 minutes to its 850°F baking temperature, and the Karu 2 Pro at about 15 minutes. Gozney lists 30 to 40 minutes for the Arc XL and 40 to 45 minutes for the Dome Gen 2. Alfa rates its Moderno gas ovens at about 30 minutes to 500°C (932°F), a fraction of the time a traditional brick oven needs.
The faster ovens are the lighter ones with thinner stone. Gozney has the best instrumentation: the Arc XL reads the stone on a built-in thermometer, and the Dome's console adds air temperature and two meat probes. With any oven, an infrared thermometer on the floor is the most reliable guide.
Which is most flexible on fuel?
- Gozney Arc and Arc XL: propane only.
- Gozney Dome Gen 2 and Dome XL: propane, wood or charcoal, with the gas burner included.
- Alfa gas ovens: the Moderno, Classico and Futuro gas models run on gas, and the Alfa Hybrid Kit protects the burner so you can build a real wood fire on the brick. Alfa also makes wood-only versions, such as the Ciao and Allegro, and several gas models come in natural gas.
- Ooni: Koda 2 Pro and Koda 2 Max come in propane or natural gas versions, chosen at purchase. Karu 2 models burn wood or charcoal, with an optional gas burner. Volt 2 is electric.
If wood flavor is the deciding factor, our gas vs wood pizza oven guide walks through the trade in detail.
Hybrid gas and wood ovens Gas pizza ovens
Not sure what fits your space? Tell us how many people you usually feed, whether there is a gas line near the patio and what will hold the oven up. Book a free design consultation and we will help you narrow it down.
Pizza ovens in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Long Island and Palm Beach County
Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens apartments. FDNY rules keep propane cylinders off balconies and terraces of residential buildings, so propane portables, including the Arc XL and most Ooni Koda models, are usually off the table on a city terrace. Co-op and condo house rules can be stricter than city code. Our terrace and rooftop grilling rules guide covers the details.
Brooklyn and Queens yards. Townhouse gardens are small and the oven lives in view, which suits a Gozney Dome or an Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze on a level, non-combustible base.
Nassau, Suffolk, the Hamptons and Westchester. More homes have a natural gas line at the patio, which favors Alfa's natural gas models in a built-in kitchen. If the oven will stay outside through a Long Island winter, read our guide on leaving a pizza oven outside in winter before you choose a cover.
Palm Beach and Martin Counties. Salt air near the coast is hard on any outdoor finish. Use the fitted cover between bakes and rinse stainless parts on a schedule, whichever brand you choose.
From our install team
On wood decks and rooftop terraces we slow people down. A 386 pound Alfa 5 Pizze on four small feet is a concentrated load, and a structural engineer should approve it. Masonry islands and paver patios take any of these ovens, and the manual is where the clearance numbers live.
Our recommended models
Chosen from the Alfa and Gozney ovens we stock, cook on and install. Each label says who the oven suits.
Shop Alfa Shop Gozney Pizza oven accessories
Shopping for someone else? Our pizza oven gift guide sorts these ovens and accessories by gift tier.
Which should you choose?
Choose Alfa if:
- You regularly feed ten or more.
- You want a brick floor for pizza, bread and roasting.
- The oven is going on a permanent base or into an outdoor kitchen.
Choose Gozney if:
- One 16 inch pizza at a time is plenty.
- The oven lives in view and design matters.
- You want wood and gas in one oven without a kit (Dome).
Choose Ooni if:
- You want the lowest entry point and the lightest oven.
- You plan to move it, store it or travel with it.
- You want an indoor electric option (Volt 2).
Our recommendation: for a family in Queens, Nassau or Westchester buying a first serious oven, the Gozney Arc XL is the simplest choice and the Dome Gen 2 is the one you keep for good. For anyone who hosts, wants a true Italian brick floor or is building an outdoor kitchen, start with the Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze and size up from there. Ooni is a sound choice when portability or budget leads.
Frequently asked questions
Is Gozney better than Ooni?
Gozney is the more premium, permanent oven, with thicker stone on the Dome, a built-in thermometer and a design-led finish. Ooni offers a wider range at lower prices and lighter, faster-heating ovens. For a fixture on the patio we lean Gozney; for portability and value, Ooni is strong.
Is Alfa better than Gozney?
For cooking more than one pizza at a time, or for bread, Alfa, because its ovens bake two to five pizzas on refractory brick. For one pizza at a time and a lighter, more designed oven, Gozney.
Which pizza oven gets the hottest?
They are close. Gozney rates its ovens at 950°F or more, Ooni at 950°F, and Alfa at 500°C (932°F). Floor thickness and recovery between pizzas matter more in practice than the top number.
Do Gozney and Ooni have the same warranty?
Both offer one year of standard coverage that extends to five years when you register the oven within 60 days. Confirm current Alfa terms with us before you order, as they vary by model.
Can I use a propane pizza oven on a NYC terrace?
Usually not. FDNY rules keep propane cylinders off balconies and terraces of residential buildings, and co-op and condo house rules can be stricter still. Check with your building before you buy.
Talk to a specialist
See Alfa and Gozney side by side in Maspeth
We have been designing, selling, installing and servicing fire features and outdoor kitchens for over 30 years across New York City, Long Island, Westchester, New Jersey and South Florida. We will help you match the oven to your patio, your gas and the way you entertain.
Book a free consultation Call 718-326-4328Showroom: 58-30 Maspeth Ave, Maspeth, Queens. Our Greenvale, Long Island showroom at 13 Glen Cove Road opens winter 2026. Plan your visit.
Related guides
Browse all buying guides and expert advice →
Written by the NYC Fireplaces & Outdoor Kitchens team. Last reviewed October 2026. We sell, install and service the products discussed here.
Sources: Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze, Alfa Forninox technology, Alfa Moderno 5 Pizze, Gozney oven comparison, Gozney warranty, Ooni published product specifications for the Karu 2, Karu 2 Pro, Koda 2 Pro and Koda 2 Max (ooni.com, October 2026). Specifications change; always confirm with the manufacturer's current installation manual.